If you were to ask for song requests in any AG church in America, I can almost guarantee someone will request “I’ll Fly Away”. For whatever reason, this song has become an American and Pentecostal favorite of previous generations. There are several reasons its popular. For one, this song has an Oklahoma connection, being written in 1932 by Alfred E. Brumley from Spiro, OK. (Check out this great article in the Tulsa World about Brumley and Spiro). Second, its is a fun song with a catchy tune. Its one of those songs you can’t help but clap and shout to. Perhaps its most notable appeal is the eschatological concept. “I’ll fly away” expresses the hope for many christians that we will one day ‘fly away’ to heaven to be with Jesus.
As a person who didn’t grow up singing this song, it doesn’t have the same sentimentality for me that it does for many Pentecostals. As a student of eschatology I have discovered that the song actually represents a very important tension in Pentecostal eschatology. Let me explain.
Pentecostals have always cherished the doctrine of the soon coming of Christ. The most important aspect in the doctrine of the rapture is that believers will be caught up to be with the Lord when he comes (1 Thess. 5:17). So when the song says, “I’ll fly away”, we immediately are filled with hope and joy that Jesus is coming.
When you look at the song there are some conflicting messages about heaven, the return of Christ and death. Let me demonstrate.
- “Some glad morning, when this life is over, I’ll fly away” – What is this phrase referring to? “When this life is over” makes me think it is about death. But death is not the rapture, although in some sense we do ‘fly away’ to heaven. But rapture is best understood as alive people being caught up and transformed as we are welcomed into heaven.
- “To a home on God’s celestial shore” – This phrase and imagery is very popular in hymnody. But notice the designation of Home. When Jesus comes, we are going home to heaven.
- “When I die, Hallelujah bye and bye, I’ll fly away.” – Again, the intention is unclear. Is this death or the rapture?
The AG believes that Jesus will return to rapture/resurrect the bride of Christ and bring her to the Marriage supper of the Lamb in Heaven. However, this will only be a temporary journey, because after a short time (most say it will be 7 years but not all) Jesus will return with his saints to set up the millennial kingdom on earth. Pentecostals understood that Heaven was Not Their Home.
Contrary to descriptions made by some scholars, Pentecostals were not “otherworldly”, at least not in an eschatological sense. They were very focused on the future of earth. Prior to about 1950, AG periodicals talked about heaven, but they did so ambiguously and rarely did they see it as our eternal home. But classical evangelical theology and hymnody such as “I’ll Fly Away” slowly began to change that orientation. In the late 1940s and 1950s, at the height of the convention song era of hymnody, songs about heaven dominated the minds of AG churches. Soon, everyone was singing, “Ill fly Away”.
As I point out in my book, and as I have discovered in my study of the first 50 years of AG eschatology, the Pentecostal hope is not going to heaven, it is that Jesus is coming to make everything new again. Heaven is not our home, the earth is our home. One day, Jesus will return to set up his kingdom “on earth as it is in heaven.” Our hope is that through the reign of Christ, the world will be transformed and all of the promises of no more curse, sin, and pain will be realized. Earth will be Heaven once more as it was in the Garden of Eden.
One AG writer put it this way in 1917,
“God has been a stranger and an outcast to His own garden because of the usurper, but the Son of the Father undertook to deal with the usurper and will not leave off till He has completed the work given to Him by His Father, so that God once more can visit His garden”. WE 216 (Nov 24, 1917), p. 4.
Similarly, S.A. Jamieson comments in 1922,
“The planet on which we live is by no means to be annihilated … As sinful man has been delivered by redemption of Jesus Christ, so this sin-cursed earth is also to share in that redemption. It is to be transformed, renew, glorified and made a fit place for the habitation of God’s redeemed people.” S.A. Jamieson, ‘A New Heavens and A New Earth’, PE 464/465 (Sep 30, 1922), p. 6.
We are Premillennial believers. We believe there will be a literal kingdom on earth and we will be in it. If we believe that, how can Heaven be our home? We will ‘fly away’, but we will also ‘fly back’ to earth.
Now you may be saying, “So what. Its just a song”. I understand. For those of you that love the song, I don’t want to diminish that love. Sing away! Its a part of our heritage. But from a eschatological perspective, as we sing these songs about heaven, just keep this in mind. Our songs shape our theology in much of the same way that this song has shaped our eschatology and the role of heaven. As believers, we are not trying to escape this world. That is not our hope. Our hope is that one day Jesus is going to fix this world. The AG has been committed to that hope for over 100 years. He created the Earth for us. The Earth also longs for our redemption (Romans 8:19-25). Eden was lost, but it will be restored when Jesus comes again. That is our hope. Not that we will live with God in heaven, but that one day God will live with us again on earth.
“Then I hears a loud voice from the throne saying, ‘Now the dwelling of God is with men and he will live with them. He will wipe very tear from their eyes.'” (Revelation 21:2-3).